Christmas is a difficult time for true Christians

Christmas is a difficult time for true Christians

Saudi Gazette Sunday, December 29, 2013

By Ray Hanania

Israel 2009

Israel 2009 (Photo credit: acroll)

Christmas is a difficult time for true Christians. It’s difficult not so much because of the religion, but because of the contrast created against it by the secular “Christians” who love the Christian life but fail to practice the fundamental tenets of Christianity. To many of the secular Christians, Christmas is about possession: Buying presents and decorations that have no real meaning in the Christian religion, other than having become a “tradition” of the secular holiday.

For me, a true Christian is someone who embraces the fundamental teachings of Jesus (peace be upon him), which involve compassion and truth. The first test of truth is to look at the City of Bethlehem, where Jesus (pbuh) was born, and begin the process there.

Do you care that Bethlehem is under oppressive siege by Israel? Are you concerned for Christians who live in the Holy Land, where Christianity first grew? Or, is Christmas just a time when you spend money on presents to give to your friends and family, and maybe, make a donation to help the poor – a donation that is often done only during the Christmas season and doesn’t represent the true spirit of “giving” all year round to those in need.

I know most Americans claim to be Christians. But when I see them turn their backs on their fellow Christians who remain in the Holy Land and live under Israeli oppression, you have to wonder how serious their concerns really are.

Last week, a Christian Palestinian who has embraced “Israel” as his nation to the point of even becoming a member of the Israeli Knesset, Hanna Sweid, asked the Speaker of the Knesset, Israel’s legislative body, if a Christmas tree could be displayed in the Knesset Plaza. The speaker of the Knesset, Yuli Edelstein, rejected the idea calling it “inappropriate.”

As an American, my mind immediately raced to the similar instances here in the United States where this Christian country always allows the display of Jewish and Muslim religious symbols at government locations. The governments just don’t sponsor them, but allows citizens to erect them.

Every year, a Menorah is displayed on the plaza of Chicago’s Cook County Building in front of City Hall, both government properties. And, they also allow the placement of the Nativity scene, although one year it was stolen.
Muslims also hold their prayers for Ramadan and officials around the country hold Eid Celebrations and Iftars to commemorate the Islamic religious “holiday.” But in Israel, which claims to be America’s closest ally and also asserts that it is a democracy, too, a Christian can’t display a Christmas tree on the plaza at the Knesset.

In nearby Bethlehem, Israeli settlers have taken over homes and lands from Christians and Muslims. Since Israel occupied Bethlehem and the Christian Triangle of Beit Sahur and Beit Jala in 1967, more than a thousand Christians have been killed by Israeli soldiers, along with tens of thousands of Muslims.

Christian citizens of Israel continue to be mistreated as second class citizens, denied fundamental rights in Israel because of their religion, just as Muslims are also discriminated against even more. Nazareth, were Jesus (pbuh) lived and worked, is abused by Israel. Although its residents are “Israeli citizens,” they are non-Jewish citizens and they receive very little in government financial support compared to the settlement of Nazareth Illit (Upper Nazareth where Israeli Jews have established an exclusive colony).

It is also true that Christians also suffer at the hands of Muslims in Palestine and in the Arab and Muslim world. Taybeh, which is the only remaining all-Christian village in Palestine has become a target of Muslim extremists. But at least the Muslim and Arab world have denounced the violence against Christians by these Muslim fanatics. Most Israelis, however, don’t care. And worse is the apathy that Christians in the West like in America show for the oppression of their brothers and sisters under Israeli occupation.

Yet American Christians fail to see the connection between what they worship and what is their religion’s reality. Christians are being persecuted in Israel. They are being stripped of their lands and their rights. They are oppressed in Israel. And American Christians could care less.

Israel struggles to keep it that way, falsely claiming they are a haven for Christians from the Arab and Muslim world. But they are not a haven. That’s why I am surprised about Edelstein’s refusal to allow the display of a Christmas tree, a non-religious symbol of Christianity to be displayed at the Knesset Plaza. It is surprising because I would have thought that Israelis would jump at the opportunity to display the tree and show how much more concerned they are for the well-being of Israeli Christians.

Edelstein’s actions in rejecting the placement of the Christmas tree only exposes the truth, that deep down, Israel holds Christians in as much disdain as they hold Muslims. It’s about who controls the land. Israel wants it and is satisfied to see the Christian population disappearing. Because once out of the way, Israel’s policies against minorities will become even more brutal.

– Ray Hanania is an award winning columnist. He can be reached at or follow him on Twitter @RayHanania

Categories: Middle East Topics

Tags: , , , , , , ,

3 replies


  1. Israel’s Christian Awakening | pundit from another planet
  2. In Middle East, Deep down, we all know that peace is best | The Arab Daily News
  3. Christian leaders condemn Israeli law to separate Christians and Muslims in Palestine - The Arab Daily News | The Arab Daily News

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: